I believe there is a serious social deficiency epidemic among the male population in the US and other english speaking countries. There are likely several reasons for this. Perhaps part of the blame goes to the fact that there are so many single-parent households. If a boy does not have a father figure in his life, very limited time with his father or a bad relationship with his father, that can hinder his development in relating to women. When it comes to how to relate to women, a boy needs a male perspective (a healthy one, that is lol) explained to him in “guy-speak”. When we take love advice from women only, it is often quite difficult to “get” what is really being said to us, especially when the words do not match the actions.
I also blame this culture of hypersensitivity and the western world’s apparent phobia of offending others. Many times, undesirable men and women are given faulty and sometimes downright deceptive advice when the fear of offending the person outweighs the benefit of stating the obvious. For example, we often tell the skinny, acne-ridden guy that he just needs self confidence, when it is obvious to ourselves that a box of Stridex pads and a gym membership would be far more beneficial to that person’s love life. Not to mention that he’s just a little dorky in the way he carries himself. Some social skills training would likely be in order as well. By giving safe, feel-good advice, we collectively put this individual in a chronicly confused state because what people are telling him does not add up to what he sees in the real world.
This brings us to pickup artists. They are on the outer fringes in regards to political correctness, yet the messages they preach are far less offensive to the lovelorn guys they are trying to reach than simply telling them to lose or gain weight, or that they are socially inept and are in dire need of getting that area fixed first. My opinion of the PUA community is mixed. I don’t particularly like the idea that they give so many guys the false hope that they will be able to pick just any hottie no matter how ugly or socially deficient they are. If a guy is short, fat, over 30 and balding, that WILL be a limiting factor, no matter how stylishly he dresses or how good his personal hygiene is. He WILL have to put in more work and suffer more trial and error to get just one bite. He WILL need a thicker skin in regards to rejection than his better looking and younger counterpart. From watching several PUA video clips scattered around the internet, I could not help but notice how often the best looking students seemed to get the best results. The undeniable and uncomfortable fact is that looks DO matter. Many gurus/leaders make at least passing mention of physical attractiveness, but fall short of telling the whole truth of just how much a man’s looks impact his game. In my estimation, a man with no game, but an Adonis-like physique would likely do much better (provided he isn’t socially impaired) than a skinny little twink with a year’s practice in learning game.
Another area where I find fault is the unnatural and fake techniques that permeate several schools of thought in the community, such as neurolinguistic programming (otherwise known as “NLP” or “speech patterns”), canned lines and canned routines. I am a bit creeped out by the thought of trying to mess with a girl’s head via NLP patterns to manipulate her into feeling attraction when she otherwise would not. My consience simply will not allow it. Though I do not condone it, I understand where these guys are coming from. Desparate situations require desparate measures and there are times when it seems that the only option out is to set aside one’s morals and ethical standards. We often say that power corrupts. Well, so does chronic subjugation and defeat. After years on end of suffering repeated bruises to the ego with little hope in sight– a suffering only romanticly undesirable individuals can understand– many are willing to adopt any dirty trick in the book within the boundries of the law if that is what it takes to dig themselves out of the bottemless pit and vicious cylce of rejection after rejection. Average folks, and especially desirable women, have absolutely no concept at all of just how much this type of situation can mess with a man’s head.
As for canned lines and routines, I can understand their use initially as examples to illustrate a concept or point more clearly. However, if a man relies too heavily on them I question his level of remedial social skills. If he has to memorize script after script, I would take that as a sign he hasn’t fully grasped the root concept that those canned lines were supposed to show, and that that concept is a bit more advanced than what a person severely lacking in basic social skills would realisticly expect to be able to grasp at that current point. My other issue with canned scripts and routines is that the man is not behaving naturally. He is giving off a false persona. Even if his target falls for him, she is falling for the persona, not HIM. I personally would not feel comfortable at all approaching women with the intent to play out a script planned in advance. This is one area where the PUA community gets a bad rap…lots of women have heard this shit before and can spot a fake from a mile away.
Like I said, canned stuff has its place in being used for practice or clarifying a point, however, I feel that the PUA community would derive more benefit (and a better repuation, I might add) if they focused more on teaching and practicing basic social skills in lieu of canned scripts. Many of the concepts taught in seduction are rather advanced and a solid foundation in remedial, fundemantal social skills is imperative if a man is to apply the advanced social concepts correctly without coming across as a complete weirdo. A good understanding of basic skills would greatly reduce the need to rely on scripts and other assorted fakery.
Negatives aside, I do see many positives with learning seduction. I have no issues whatsoever with natural game– learning how to relate to women properly and most importantly, learning how NOT to make a total ass out of one’s self. The more natural schools of thought seem to be more focused on what NOT to do and avoiding behaviors that turn women off. I see much more emphasis put on social skills in these schools of thought, as well as more emphasis on theory and just being your best self. Not just yourself, but a more socially aware, better self.
Too many men are left in the dark when it comes to how to properly relate to women. Being smart or nice with nothing else to offer just doesn’t cut it, but all that warm fuzzy bullshit advice floating around these days can lead a man sufficiently lacking in social awareness to believe otherwise in spite of his obvious lack of success with women. I applaud the PUA community for calling the so-called dating “experts” on their steaming piles of useless bullshit and at least offering a glimmer of hope to undesirable and unnatractive men by giving them a way out of their prediciment. Far too many undesirable males have followed the advice of dating experts only to continue to get burned over and over again. Far too many have had sneaking suspicions in the backs of their minds that there was something amiss about the popular, tired, cliched advice we have all heard a million times.
One final thought…if approached with a pure motive– to find true love and keep it– the natrual schools of the seduction arts community are excellent for teaching a man how to have an attractive personality– one of the very things that women find attractive. Now he will have something to offer other than intelligence or niceness. Even if he is ugly, at least now he has SOMETHING that will give him a means to attract women and the confidence that comes with it.